Carl Gibson - Chapter One

Label / Cat. No: Ebony Records - ERC1 
First Released: 1978 

What The Album Blurb Says...

Carl Gibson, being of Cherokee Indian descent, is one of the most fiercely independent men I know, (this being a typical Indian trait). He created this record almost entirely alone and unaided. It has been my privilege to witness a great talent at work. His "Sessions" in the studio would make good writing for a "Best Seller" alone. His moods during the recording, the anguish when he fell short of his aims, his great elation when "things" went right. He is voted by Opinion Poll as one of the World's leading "Country Fingerstyle Guitarists", to me, after watching him, this is an understatement!!! His Vocal Range is second to none. To see him "LIVE" is sensational, but it's impossible to appreciate his great talent by just one or even two performances. He created this Album with just his voice, one electric guitar, one acoustic guitar, bass and a tambourine, and his deep determination to 'achieve'. Well, he certainly has achieved, in this case, a more beautiful portrayal of Vocal and Instrumental talent than I've ever heard in this field before. His outstanding arrangements of 'Ghost Riders' and 'Skip-a-Rope" are, I'm sure, going to be among the biggest hits in the field of Country, since they were first written two decades ago. I may add at this stage, that he puts great store by his choice of sound engineer Des Bennett, the only other person to work with Carl on the Album. He acknowledges Des to be certainly one of the best in Britain today...

Carl has just one particular life-long friend who has recently become his co-producer and adviser, Jeff Purnell. In General Production, Research, Publicity Promotions and the fiercely competitive field of Marketing, Jeff has no equal! He handles all of these with a quiet but extremely powerful driving force, as well as being an influence on Carl, which proves a steadying effect. Every decade carries a provincial "Star Maker". I believe Jeff Purnell to be in this category.

"Chapter One" can only pave the way to Chapter Two, Chapter Th.....



What I Say

I would have thought it a pretty basic requirement that the person writing your sleeve notes should probably like you. It can only help to sell your record if you get a kind word or two extolling your virtues, and saying what a great singer / musician / human being you are. At first glance, it seems that Patti Noble is doing a fantastic job at selling Carl Gibson - if you take the gushing prose at face value, you'd think that here was a talent unparalleled in the Country Music field, that Patti had discovered a new Dylan or McCartney.

But look a bit closer. He's described variously as 'fiercely independent' (read: stubborn, awkward and impossible to work with), has only one life-long friend (is anti-social), and needs a 'steadying effect' (is difficult to manage). Underneath the high praise, I think that Patti's had just about all she can of Carl's artistic temperament, and this is her chance to let the world know what he's really like. She'd have been more honest if she'd just scrawled 'I think this man is an absolute shit' across the back of the album.

Oh well, I can't vouch for his character, but I hardly think it's surprising that a Cherokee might harbour a tendency towards fierce independence. You can hardly blame them.

Of course, talk about Native American musicians, and thoughts turn immediately to Jimmy Carl Black. What do you mean who? Jimmy Carl Black was a member of Frank Zappa's original 'Mother's of Invention' which in my eyes elevates him to hero status without question. Oops - I've given to much away. Anyway, my mate Shaun, through a series of 'too complicated to go into now circumstances' once let Jimmy sleep in his bed. Jimmy duly thanked Shaun by autographing his toilet door. When Shaun then moved house from Haringey to Lewes, the door moved with them. Some poor sod bought a nice house in London without a toilet door all because of Frank Zappa's drummer.

Well, it's not much of an anecdote, but at least it's 100% true. And besides, it's curious to notice that Carl and Jimmy share a moustache. Well, I don't mean they have one between them, but they both wear the same style. I am ignorant of Indian ways, so I can't venture an opinion as to whether it's part of their cultural heritage, but personally I think it's probably just a coincidence.

Anyway, back to the album. I think it was a brave assertion of Patti Noble's that this 'Chapter One' would pave the way for future Chapters. I have to say, I've scoured the internet, and I can't find any mention of Carl, let alone of Chapter's Two, Three or beyond. I assume it's safe to say that this was pretty much it, and that it failed to live up to the high ambitions that Carl held. It also strikes me that this being record catalog number ERC1 that this was probably something of a vanity project, and that Ebony Records didn't survive (in this incarnation at least) very much after this album was released.

I mean, Carl has an OK voice - he can hold a tune which is more than I can. He seems to have quite a range, demonstrated in 'Ghost Riders' and 'Rose Marie' where the high notes are frankly scary. His guitar picking is fine. What more can I say? It's fine. 

But this album doesn't make any kind of statement. It's a competent musician playing it safe with a pile of standards. There's no individuality, nothing to make this stand out against the other countless covers of 'Ruby' (Don't Take Your Love To Town) or 'Rose Marie'. I'm not searching for endless novelty, and there's no point in change for the sake of it, but I think it goes some way to explaining why Carl Gibson isn't remembered as an outstanding international artist. There is no character or personality in this album. It's just those same old songs. Again.

If there is anything that marks this album out, it's that Carl has a tendency to sound anguished. Yes, he does anguished very well. The cries of 'Johnny , remember me' closing the song of the same name takes that 60s schlock to a whole new level. But this anguish is best demonstrated on 'Scarborough Fair', my favourite track from this album. The 'remember me to one who lives there' no longer sounds like a request to send your best wishes, but an animal response to being forgotten by your true love. It actually made me stop in my tracks and listen, which was a nice contrast to the rest of the album.

If only he hadn't followed it by an overly jangly and jolly version of 'Ring of Fire'. The fool.

No Carl Gibson, I'm afraid, so here's the original JCB instead...

Sound Clips



Side 1


1. Ghost Riders
2. Okie From Muskogee
3. Fight'n Side Of Me
4. Scarborough Fair
5. Ring of Fire
6. Johnny Remember Me
7. Bobbie Magee

Side 2

1. Skip-a-Rope
2. There'll Never Be
3. Rose Marie
4. Ruby
5. Lonesome Me
6. Spanish Eyes
7. Phoenix Arizona

Final score:

3 out of 10, (2 points for Scarborough Fair, 1 for Johnny Remember Me)

Write a comment

Comments: 6
  • #1

    John Richardson (Tuesday, 11 September 2018 03:21)

    Thanks for the totally unqualified, ignorant summary. He lost all his fingers in an accident involving farming equipment after Chapter One and that put an end to his musical career. Those who had the privilege of hearing him perform live will tell you he was an extraordinary talent who would no doubt have gone on to great heights. Such a combination of vocals and guitar talent is rare. Perhaps his fierce independence was an impediment to the production quality on this album. His mesmerising live performances should be what he is remembered for.

  • #2

    Cherry Jenkins (Monday, 04 March 2019 21:50)

    I remember Carl and his wife Patti. I dated his back up disco guy Steve so that’s how we met. Carl was amazing , going to a few of his shows.
    Amazing guy , it’s a shame we lost touch.

  • #3

    Johnny Caesar (Sunday, 07 June 2020 17:55)

    I have just come across this pathetic review of Carl Gibson. Obviously written by some talentless individual who only seems to be interested in his character than his talent I was part of a team that managed Carl and wrote "Thats what life is for" a song he recorded (see You Tube ) He was hard to handle and manage but what great talent isn't You had to see him live, he was outstanding Just a guy a guitar and a drum machine with a vocal range to die for and as for his guitar pickin he was a one man orchestra. I have written songs that have been recorded by many artists including Sir Tom Jones but if I could have the choice of any of the great voices I would coose Carl Gibsons Brilliant

  • #4

    Forgotten Albums (Sunday, 07 June 2020 18:31)

    Hi Johnny, and thanks for taking the time to comment. I have to say that over the years that I've been operating this stupid little site, this post has generated the most comment, both here and on it's original home. It's clear that Carl Gibson's fans are exceedingly loyal, and see in him something that I didn't pick up on when I listened to this album, just the once, 12 years ago. As I've mentioned elsewhere, when I first started this site, it was about instant reactions to an album, both in terms of its sleeve and contents. Of course I never saw Carl live, as I'd not heard of him before picking up the album, and I have no other connection than this single listen, so my appreciation of what he can do is not going to be the same as someone who worked with him or saw him live several times. However, as I said, this review has garnered the most negative response to my comments, closely followed by one other. The fairest thing I can think of is to listen to it again, and re-appraise the album, but bear in mind, I might not have changed my mind in the meantime. If you think this is something I should do, please let me know below, and I'll happily give the record another spin and put down my thoughts about the music alone. Fair?

  • #5

    Johnny Caesar (Sunday, 07 June 2020 19:49)

    Hi I dont see the point of listening to the album again you had to see him live which sadly will never happen again however I agree the albums sound quality is poor I think Ebony Records was Carls own label and was made in a poor quality studio. The only time he was in a top recording studio I think was in Holland where he recorded Ghost Riders and the song I wrote "Thats what Life is for" to get a better Idea of his Voice listen on you tube to "Thats what life is for" listen to the last note of the song then try and name any singer in the world who could do that, there is nothing faked about it in fact the producer made him do it about 8 times before he was happy, Incredible

  • #6

    Amanda Simmonds (Saturday, 26 September 2020 15:19)

    can anyone help ???
    My grandparents are Huge fans of Carl, seeing him on a number of occasions in Aberdare, I'm trying to find out if anyone has or knows where I can get hold of a CD version of His album ? This would truly make their day and make me the best grandaughter ever !!